*Last Updated 8/13/2022
The Jason Bourne franchise was a burst of fresh air in 2002 when it brought a new feeling of focus and realism to the action genre that had begun to be increasingly dominated by Die Hard ripoffs, special effect extravaganzas, a Bond stuck in goofier and goofier set pieces, and mostly failed attempts to crossover Hong Kong action into America. I now think of the Bourne films as the standard setter for the urban hybrid chase/fight (check out my top four picks). Although the Bourne series would eventually become known as the trendsetter when it came to quick edits and shaky cam (this didn't really happen until Paul Greengrass took over on The Bourne Supremacy), I felt it never deserved this criticism and isn't responsible for the negative use of those elements in lesser and later films.
You see, action "styles" are fairly neutral things - they are simply tools for getting the job done. You can use a hammer correctly and you can use a hammer incorrectly. Action scenes are similar in that you can use a style well or horribly. I generally prefer action sequences that favor wide shots that allow the athleticism / spectacle of whatever is going to be spatially understood and have a clear geographical context. However, using this style poorly can result in a very flat and boring sequence - it's not the right tool for everything. The "shaky cam" style (as it would come to be known) requires a smart use and implementation and I think Greengrass is still the best user of this method - this series being the example. However, poor use of this style - like this famous overedited sequence from Taken 3 - is not his fault.
For those interested in knowing before you get into the ratings, here's how I would rank the current five films in the franchise:
5. The Bourne Legacy (C+) 2012
Outside of the first two entries, I think the stories have greatly suffered, even if there style continues to provide engaging moments and actions sequences. If the franchise ends at 5, it will have a strong legacy. The style of the Bourne series injected new life into action films and has given us some of the best contemporary fight sequences and chases of all-time. Enjoy.
4. Jason Bourne (C+) 2016
3. The Bourne Ultimatum (C+) 2007
2. The Bourne Identity (A) 2002
1. The Bourne Supremacy (A+) 2004
Outside of the first two entries, I think the stories have greatly suffered, even if there style continues to provide engaging moments and actions sequences. If the franchise ends at 5, it will have a strong legacy. The style of the Bourne series injected new life into action films and has given us some of the best contemporary fight sequences and chases of all-time. Enjoy.
All Bourne Action Scenes Graded & Ranked
GRADE: C
Mediocre sequences that lack anything that makes them stand out. Decent, but forgettable.
19. “Jason Bourne takes out Treadstone in Paris” -The Bourne Identity (2002)
- Commentary: While this sequence works dramatically, I’d say it is the first time an action scene kinda disappoints in this series. The consulate escape, pen fight, paris car chase, and shootout in the woods all demonstrated a unique aspect of Bourne’s skills. As an action climax, this fails. It doesn’t demonstrate a new ability or even top anything that’s come before. That doesn’t mean it’s bad – it’s just a pretty typical fight/shootout with an over the top stunt (using a dead body to break a fall down a stairwell) that really doesn’t belong in the franchise. Thankfully, Greengrass seems to have chosen to let that “crazy stunt” template die with this sequence.
GRADE: C+
Largely mediocre sequences that have some redeeming or standout feature. This, to me, is where the average decent action sequence ranks.
18. "Snowy Strategy: Cross vs. Drones & Wolves" -The Bourne Legacy (2012)
- Commentary: A simple sequence that shows off the intelligence of Aaron Cross here. He is being tracked by wolves and a government drone looking to take him out. He captures a wolf in a trap, wrestles it and sticks his GPS tracker inside the mouth of the wolf. The drone ultimately takes out the wolf instead of Aaron. Simple, but effective.
17. "Escaping a Manilla Pill Factory" -The Bourne Legacy (2012)
- Commentary: The Bourne series became well-known for its intense foot chase sequences spiked with moments of fighting. Without Greengrass at the helm, this sequence feels more like a sub-par copy of that trope rather than the genuine article. Still, it's a sequence worth a watch.
GRADE: B-
Good sequences that have some issue holding it back from being solid.
16. “Assassin Finds Bourne in Goa” -The Bourne Supremacy (2004)
- Commentary: Hiding out in Goa, India – Bourne spots a suspicious man (who is there to assassinate him) in town. He immediately feels this is his past reaching out to get him. He races to get to Marie before the mysterious man. He picks her up, but the assassin notices them and a chase ensues. The car chase through the town is hectic and choppy making great use of the dirt alleys and heavy foliage of the location. As they approach a major bridge the assassin takes a sniper shot at Marie and takes her out. The car crashes into the river and Marie dies. Bourne barely escapes. It’s a jarring scene that’s meant to be more than just an action set piece, it's meant to throw Bourne’s existence into sudden drama and conflict. It accomplishes this part extremely well.
15. “Fighting the Asset in Vegas” -Jason Bourne (2016)
- Commentary: Coming at the end of the final film in the franchise - this decent fight against Vincent Cassel just underwhelms when put next to its franchise brethren. This fight takes place in a pretty non-descript sewer area and features usual object fighting (it's a pot and wire this time), but this feels like a fight that could've come from any number of the Bourne-imitation films that came out in its wake. Standalone - it's serviceable, but as a finale - it's weak.
14. House Shootout: Cross Saves Shearing From Agents" -The Bourne Legacy (2012)
- Commentary: CIA agents arrive at Shearing's home (Rachel Weisz) and their job is to ultimately make it look like she committed suicide. Aaron Cross arrives and gums up the works. Cross shows off some tactical fighting skills, but the big open home allows him a chance to retreat and hide as well. He makes it to a basement where he sets a few traps for agents, then makes his way to help out Shearing. It's a decent little shootout showing more of Aaron's skills - but there's nothing that remarkable or special here.
13. “Bourne vs the Professor: Shotgun in the Woods” -The Bourne Identity (2002)
- Commentary: This assassin face-off is a nice little breath of fresh air that’s more about positioning than about brute force. Bourne is staying at Marie’s relatives house and after the kids come back in the morning saying the dogs are not around Bourne knows something is up. After guessing at the assassin’s position, he grabs a shotgun and shoots a propane tank to distract the assassin (Clive Owen) with a large explosion. This gives Bourne the cover to take better ground. He confidently makes his way out into the woods to flank. When he’s confident the assassin has taken a position in some tall grass he fires to scatter the birds and give even more cover. Ultimately, Owen is outmatched and is seen moving positions, and gets gunned down. It’s a nice cat and mouse game that makes Bourne look able to beat others not just with brute force but with intelligence.
12. “Escaping the American Consulate” -The Bourne Identity (2002)
11. “Chase in New York: Bourne vs Paz” -The Bourne Ultimatum (2007)
- Commentary: This is a good sequence…it’s not a bad one…yet I can’t help but be disappointed by it. You see, the car chase in Paris from the first movie is an old-school epic and the car chase in Moscow is one of my all-time favorites. When I heard the trilogy was going to feature a car chase in New York – my mind raced with the possibilities. What we get here is…a cool stunt off a parking complex, a decent chase through some New York streets playing bumper cars, and an impressive car wreck as the culmination. That sounds great, but it just never quite clicks like the others – I think because the pacing of the film makes this just feel like another beat rather than a major beat. Whatever it is, its something that really pales in comparison with its peers in the series.
GRADE: B
Good action sequences with much to commend about them. They are a solid entry into their genre.
10. “Berlin Foot Chase: Hotel to the Train” -The Bourne Supremacy (2004)
Commentary: This is a great example of how the Bourne series used action sequences to help unveil exposition, rather than just counting on slow dramatic scenes to do it. Bourne visits a hotel where he believes he may have done an operation in his past. As he is exploring and discovering his past (dramatic flashbacks help the significance of the moment a lot here), the authorities are on to him and closing in. Once the authorities swarm in the chase is on and like the trend established in the consulate scene from the first movie – these chases are more about intelligence and small bursts of action than they are on pure spectacle. The editing style supports this by often throwing 3-4 edits of close-up movement followed by a wider shot (establishing space and geography) held just a bit longer. The iconic driving score backing this works perfectly. This pattern does an excellent job of conveying the intensity and split-second choices that need to be made to escape authorities. Bourne here climbs alongside of the building, escapes across rooftops and onto the street where cops pick him up and per the tradition he must quickly glance at a subway tram schedule and he is off to try and outwit them, which he does over a tram station and bridge.
9. "Athens Riot & Motorcycle Chase" -Jason Bourne (2016)
- Commentary: Not perfectly, but this sequence does a good job recapturing and combining the magic of the classic surveillance and chase sequences of the previous entries into the franchise. A bit sloppy and convoluted, but its hard to deny the spectacle, visuals, and driving energy of this sequence.
GRADE: B+
Very good action sequences with something holding them back from greatness. These sequences are typically best in their film and represent something above and beyond expectations.
8. "Bourne Protecting Ross at Waterloo Station" -The Bourne Ultimatum (2007)
- Commentary: A British journalist investigating CIA practices has shownn up on the radar of both Jason Bourne and the CIA. In an attempt to learn the journalists source, Jason Bourne tries to meet surreptitiously with Bourne in London's Waterloo Station. It's an incredibly busy transport hub in crowded London, but the CIA has surveillance and grab teams everywhere. Greengrass has used this moment to make a unique kind of action/chase sequence that doesn't feature a ton of fighting or shots fired, but is about the cat and mouse game between Bourne keeping Ross safe and out of sight and the CIA trying to observe and grab him. For me, this sequence represents the best of several “countering surveillance” sequence in the franchise. This is the Alexanderplatz sequence from Bourne Supremacy on steroids. There's a scene in the Bourne Identity at a rest stop where Bourne tells Marie that for some reason he knows how many exits the building has, how many people are in the room, and other various important information. This sequence demonstrates just how trained Bourne is at noticing his surrounding, keeping out of view, etc. Bourne, with all his knowledge and skills, works behind the scenes to keep the British journalist away from CCTV cameras and grab teams. As he subtly guides the journalist through a phone he planted on him, he also has to lure CIA grab teams into corridors where he can take them out in short fight sequences. The camerawork, sharp editing, and classic building score combine perfectly here with the structured action to make a basic surveillance sequence into something unique and gripping.
7. "Manilla Maze: Foot & Motorcycle Chase Thru the City" -The Bourne Legacy (2012)
6. “Swat Tank Chase in Vegas” -Jason Bourne (2016)
- Commentary: After a somewhat underwhelming New York city car chase in the previous film, Greengrass and Damon come back with a classic Vegas chase on the strip. Bourne, in a Dodge Challenger, is chasing Vincent Cassel who has commandeered a SWAT armored vehicle. This sequence might be fairly linear, but they really rack up the damage - at one point the armored vehicle just plows into two lanes of cars in traffic to incredible results. The chase moves from the strip to a parking lot and back to the strip for a couple of more stunts. Lots of strong practical stunt work in an age where everyone else is using CGI.
GRADE: A-
These are great action sequences with some minor issue(s) holding them back. They are typically best in their film and potentially best of the year.
5. “The Pen Fight” -The Bourne Identity (2002)
4. “Munich Magazine Fight” -The Bourne Supremacy (2004)
- Commentary: I know that I will get a lot of people questioning my judgment by rating this fight this high, but I don’t care, I love this fight. Many will say this fight is a perfect example of the overuse of “shaky cam” and quick editing. In most films, in lesser creative hands, I usually agree with that sentiment. However, to put that criticism on THIS fight is to actually miss what the director Paul Greengrass and his editor are trying to do. This is all about two equally matched and highly trained men, unsure about each other, doing mental and physical battle. This isn't about flashy fighting, this is about men trying to take control over the other. Greengrass is trying to ground Bourne's fighting with another agent as much as possible, while still retaining a cinematic flare. Bourne arrives at the Munich home of another Treadstone operative played by Martin Csokas looking for information. When Csokas arrives home he knows something is up and after pulling a gun from the fridge, realizes that Bourne has already emptied it. He stays calm and begins approaching him as Bourne motions for him to get his hands cuffed in plastic rings. Csokas talks calmy and confidently, always moving forward into Bourne space - forcing him to back up and putting him on his toes. I LOVE the cat and mouse you can tell is happening from these operatives in these games. It sets an uneasy tone and marks Csokas as a potential equal for Bourne. Once Csokas plays his hand to distract Bourne, the fight is on. I don’t think you can really enjoy this fight with enjoying three key things about it. First, how the intellectual cat and mouse turns into an athletic cat and mouse game. The fighting here isn’t about flashy martial arts, but about getting the practical upper hand – so anything at their disposal is fair game. Oh, you got a knife, I’ll grab this…magazine? Second, how the costume design and art direction of the apartment come together to turn Bourne and Csokas into black figures essentially silhouetted among the modern white vibe of the apartment. There are moments here when the guys wrestle against the blinds that are breathtaking in my opinion. Third, how the editing/camera work together to present a fight that’s for three quarters is about an intense struggle and for one quarter is about big and pleasing fight moves. All of these combine to make a sudden fight scene that goes back and forth and pops with moments of dazzling visuals and violence, but always feels grounded. The “shaky cam” editing is essentially throwing four or so quick edits at you but then one or two longer (relatively) wider shots to establish a bigger move/geography, then right back at the quick edits. This technique is used to great effect later in the Berlin chase as well. My favorite moment here is Bourne’s use of a rolled up magazine (continuing the Bourne tradition of making everyday objects violent). There’s a moment, one of those longer edited shots, where Bourne strikes Csokas with the magazine in a wide shot set against the blinds that never fails to bring a smile to my face. In the category of grounded fights – I just think this one is practically perfect from beginning to end. If I was looking for flashy or showy, I’d go elsewhere. So there you go – there’s my arguments. Have I convinced you? Do you think this is an underrated and misunderstood fight too?
3. “Paris Chase in a Mini-Cooper” -The Bourne Identity (2002)
- Commentary: To get to Paris Jason Bourne pays a woman named Marie to drive him in her mini car. After a murdered CIA assassin gets authorities riled up, Bourne and Marie need to go on the run. Cornered at a train station they have to run. Bourne takes a look at Paris map and hits the road. The sequence is a jolt of electricity from beginning to end. Weaving in and out of streets and alleys, the mini car allows the chase to go places many others can’t – including driving down a set of stairs. There is a nice sequence where Bourne drives along the Seine River the wrong way, leading to some nice damage and stunts. This is a classic car chase shot in the old school style – practical and on-location. It's a bit short for my tastes, but this is great stuff.
2. “Tangiers Chase & Fight: Bourne vs. Desh” -The Bourne Ultimatum (2007)
GRADE: A+
An all-time great action sequence. This does not mean it is a technically perfect action sequence, just that it is "perfect" to me. This is one I can watch over and over and it doesn't lose its power.
2. “Tangiers Chase & Fight: Bourne vs. Desh” -The Bourne Ultimatum (2007)- Commentary: Although I don't think this sequence is better than my number one pick, I do think it picks up on the formula and evolves it into something uniquely entertaining in the "Bourne" style. A CIA leaker named Daniels is currently in Tangiers and Bourne as well as a CIA assassin named Desh are out to find him. This lengthy and iconic chase sequence is broken up into several phases. The first phase is presented much like the earlier surveillance sequence at Waterloo station - cutting back and forth from CIA HQ and to our main characters as the chess pieces move on the board...that classic "Bourne" musical score continuing to build in the background. Desh ultimately gets one up on Bourne and is able to kill Daniels through a cleverly hidden bomb on a route that Daniels is driving. It's an explosive moment that ends the "surveillance" phase and kicks off the next and more kinetic "chase" phase of the sequence. Desh is on a scooter and his next target is Nikki Parsons while Bourne is following behind him on a dirt bike with the police on his tail. This phase feels much like Bourne Supremacy's "Berlin Hotel to Subway Chase" but done in daylight and played out with more time.
This phase captures the unique textures of the city so well with alleys, crowds, pot holes, cares, plazas, and stairs all flashing by in that classic Bourne style. The chase then moves from vehicles on the busy streets to a foot chase through tight residential squares. To get away from the crowded alleys, and the police, Bourne takes to the rooftops. I love how we he to jump between residential blocks giving us a new view of the unique city and providing us with that iconic shot of him jumping through a window. There's lovely little details peppered throughout these moments that are so enjoyable and set Bourne sequences like this apart from so many other franchises. For example, as a way to cause a distraction and get the police off his back, Bourne grabs a paint can (or some kind of pressured container) from a vendor in an alley and throws it into a food vendor's grill causing a small explosion. Another example is how Bourne grabs linen from rooftop laundry lines to protect his hands from the glass lining rooftops and keeping people away. This all eventually culminates in a superlative fight sequence against Desh. It's quick, hard hitting, and features all the main staples of Bourne fights - confined spaces, non-flashy martial arts, and using everyday objects at hand to his advantage (in this case a book and a towel). For what it is going for, this just might be the pinnacle of the Hollywood spy chase. It's the culmination of a Paul Greengrass formula begun in The Bourne Supremacy and built on here.
1. “Chased on Foot and Car in Moscow” -The Bourne Supremacy (2004)
- Commentary: The quintessential Jason Bourne sequence to me is an extended and increasingly intense urban chase punctuated by a visceral fight or car chase. The top two action sequences on the list are the epitome of what this series does and compose the top shelf of "grounded" spy action. This style after The Bourne Supremacy was so influential that Martin Campbell essentially spent the first hour of James Bond's 2006 reboot Casino Royale in Bourne's image. This sequence begins with Bourne making a trip to Moscow to find the daughter of someone the Russian figures he learns he assassinated when he was in Treadstone. Before he finds the girl, the authorities and the assassin, played by Karl Urban, are on to him. What ensues is the best action sequence in the franchise. An already injured Bourne is forced to flee on foot when his taxi driver learns he is a wanted man and high tails it out of there. Luckily, Urban spots Bourne walking along a riverway and is able to get a shot off into his shoulder, causing Bourne even more injury. The bleeding Bourne makes his way through some underground walkways and into a market where he grabs items to deal with his injury (alcohol, a wrap) and, yep, a road map for the chase he knows is happening. Urban and the authorities are always a step behind this foot chase. At one point he is stopped by cops and taxi men and is forced to fight them off.
He gets in the taxi and the car chase is now on. If the Paris chase was a classic of traditional car chases – then this one is a classic of a brand new style. Using his unique editing and camera work – Greengrass conveys a wild and brutal car chase through Moscow. High speeds, big roads, and lots of damage to Bourne’s car happens here – all the while Bourne is pouring alcohol on his wound, overlooking a Moscow map, and shifting gears like a mad man. This is the first car chase I can recall watching that sometimes feels like its in a destruction derby. Along with this new emphasis on self-damage, you get a lot of the classic tropes here – last second turns, going the wrong way, destruction – but they feel incredibly fresh in Greengrass’s style and the driving beat of the score. The scene finishes off with a heck of an impactful stunt done in a tunnel. This is a masterpiece.
Comments
Post a Comment